A Diskussion is a structured talk about a question where people share different Meinungen (opinions). You state your Meinung and back it with a Begründung (reason): 'Ich finde…, weil…'.
Good discussing means listening to others, taking their points seriously, and responding to them: agree ('Da stimme ich zu'), disagree with a reason ('Ich sehe das anders, weil…'), or ask ('Kannst du das erklären?'). Stay respectful — attack the argument, not the person.
A common mistake is to attack the person instead of the point ('Du verstehst nichts'). That ends the discussion and convinces nobody. Keep your reply on the argument: say what you think about the idea, and why, and the discussion can move forward.
Discuss = share Meinung + Begründung ('Ich finde…, weil…'), listen, respond to others' points, stay respectful. Attack the argument, not the person.
Worked examples
1Respond to another view
Someone says: «Handys sollten in der Schule erlaubt sein.»
Disagree with a reason: «Ich sehe das anders, weil Handys im Unterricht ablenken.»
Or build on it: «Da stimme ich zu, aber nur in den Pausen — denn im Unterricht lenken sie ab.»
2Turn a personal attack into a point about the argument
Attack on the person: «Du verstehst doch gar nichts!»
Shift it onto the idea, and add a reason.
On the argument: «Ich sehe das anders, weil dein Beispiel nur selten vorkommt.»
Practise it — free, no sign-up
Have a go right here. Nothing is saved and you can retry as much as you like. Create a free account when you want to save your progress and get Archie, your tutor.
1A good contribution to a discussion contains…
2How do you disagree well in a discussion?
3«Attack the argument, not the person» means…
4Listening to others is part of a good discussion.
5You can disagree in a discussion as long as you stay respectful.
6Which TWO are respectful ways to respond in a discussion?
7«Du verstehst nichts» is a fair way to disagree in a discussion.
8What makes «Ich finde…» a strong discussion contribution?
9In a discussion you should take others' points seriously and respond to them.
10Which is a respectful way to ask for more in a discussion?
11Which TWO are poor discussion moves?
Create a free account to save your progress, track mastery and ask Archie, your tutor, for a hand.